BRANCH TAX versus DIVIDEND WITHHOLDING TAX 

Non-Resident Ownership  |  Active Business  |  Passive Commercial  |  Real Estate Investment  |  Returning Profits Home

For non-residents investing in Canada, contact our law firm at Chris@NeufeldLegal.com - 403-400-4092 / 905-616-8864

For non-resident business enterprises entering the Canadian market, whether as a branch or a Canadian subsidiary, its chosen structure will determine the tax mechanism used by the Canada Revenue Agency to tax the repatriation of its profits. Both the Branch Tax (Part XIV tax) and the Non-Resident Dividend Withholding Tax (Part XIII tax) serve a common purpose: to ensure that non-resident investors pay a final level of Canadian tax equivalent to the dividend tax that would be paid if profits were distributed from a domestically incorporated entity. However, they differ significantly in their legal application, timing, and base of calculation. The Branch Tax applies to the after-tax profits of a foreign corporation's branch operations in Canada, whereas the Dividend Withholding Tax is a levy imposed on the gross amount of certain passive payments, most notably dividends, paid by a Canadian-resident corporation to its non-resident shareholders.

The most critical distinction lies in the legal structure to which each tax applies. Dividend Withholding Tax applies when profits are earned by a legally distinct Canadian-resident subsidiary and are subsequently paid out to its non-resident parent company in the form of dividends. Since the subsidiary is a Canadian resident, it first pays regular Part I corporate income tax on its worldwide income. The Part XIII withholding tax is then applied to the dividend itself at the time of payment, serving as a second layer of tax on the corporate income repatriated. In contrast, the Branch Tax is an additional tax imposed directly on the Canadian earnings of a non-resident corporation that carries on business in Canada through a branch. The branch is not a separate legal entity; it is merely an extension of the foreign head office. Therefore, the Branch Tax is needed to mimic the secondary tax that a subsidiary would have faced upon distributing its earnings.

A significant practical difference exists in the timing and calculation of the tax base. Dividend Withholding Tax is a cash-basis tax, triggered only when a physical or deemed dividend payment is actually paid or credited by the Canadian subsidiary to the non-resident shareholder. The amount subject to tax is the gross dividend payment. The Branch Tax, conversely, is assessed on an accrual basis, applying annually to the branch's after-tax income that is not deemed to be reinvested in qualifying property in the Canadian business. This means the Branch Tax can be due even if the non-resident corporation has not physically removed (repatriated) the profits from Canada. The base for the Branch Tax is the branch’s taxable income earned in Canada, net of Part I Canadian corporate tax and an allowance for investment in Canadian property.

The statutory rate for both the Branch Tax and the Dividend Withholding Tax under the Income Tax Act (Canada) is generally 25%. However, this domestic rate is almost always reduced under Canada's extensive network of bilateral tax treaties. A core principle of the Canadian tax system is that tax treaties often harmonize the rates. For instance, a tax treaty that reduces the dividend withholding tax rate on certain inter-corporate dividends (e.g., to 5% or 10%) typically reduces the Branch Tax rate to the same percentage. Furthermore, some treaties offer special relief for the Branch Tax, such as a cumulative profit exemption threshold (like the $500,000 exemption found in the Canada-U.S. tax treaty), which is generally not available for Dividend Withholding Tax.

The interplay of these two taxes is a central consideration in international tax planning. Operating through a branch exposes the business to two layers of tax (Part I corporate tax and Part XIV Branch Tax) right from the point of earning and non-reinvestment, but losses incurred by the branch might be immediately deductible in the foreign parent's home jurisdiction. Conversely, operating through a Canadian subsidiary means losses are trapped locally, but the second layer of tax (Part XIII Dividend Withholding Tax) is deferred until the distribution of profits is actively made. Therefore, the decision between the two structures often hinges on the expectation of initial profitability, the foreign parent's ability to utilize foreign tax credits, and the specific relief provisions available under the applicable tax treaty.

For knowledgeable and experienced tax, investment and corporate law representation for non-residents looking to invest in Canada, whether through active business enterprises, passive income investments or real estate investments, we welcome you to contact our law firm for strategic legal advice to optimize your commercial interests in Canada at Chris@NeufeldLegal.com or call 403-400-4092 / 905-616-8864.

NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Information made available on this website in any form is for information purposes only. It is not, and should not be taken as legal advice or tax advice. You should not rely upon, or take or fail to take any action, based upon this information. Never disregard professional legal advice or delay in seeking legal advice because of something you have read on this website. The law firm of Neufeld Legal PC would be pleased to discuss legal matters referenced in this website upon their retention in accordance with applicable requirements pertaining to client retention by this law firm. Thank you.